Peter Grimes. Metropolitan Opera 2008. Production: John Doyle. Cast: Anthony Dean Griffey (Peter Grimes), Patricia Racette (Ellen Orford), Anthony Michaels-Moore (Bastrode), Teddy Tahu Rhodes (Ned Keene), Jill Grove (Auntie), Felicity Palmer (Mrs Sedley), Anthony Michaels-Moore (Balstrode). Conductor: Donald Runnicles. Further information here.
Whatever else you may think of John Doyles 2008 production of Peter Grimes for the Metropolitan Opera, shown in HD and now released on DVD, you may agree that it is dark.
Dominated by a black on black uniwall with multiple windows, from which the inhabitants of Borough peep out. The sea is far away from this Peter Grimes. The claustrophobia of Borough is tangible. As it should be, in my opinion.
Anthony Dean Griffey is a superb Peter Grimes. A relatively light tenor, providing a fascinating insights into Peter Grimes. This is not the brooding, almost menacingly haunted portrait of a Jon Vickers. Rather Griffey´s Grimes is an outsider, who only wants to belong, but doesn´t succeed. A very moving portrait.
Patricia Racette virtually shines as Ellen Orford, one of her best roles. Several of the minor parts positively lit up the stage as well, particularly Teddy Tahu Rhodes in his house debut as Ned Keene, Felicity Palmer as the pathetic Mrs Sedley and a well-sung Aunt from Jill Grove.
A major part of the success is attributable to the fine playing from the Met Orchesta in a slow, undulating reading from Donald Runnicles.
Highly recommended. Another fine recent alternative is David Pountney´s production from Zurich.
The bottom line (scale of 1-5, 3=average):
Anthony Dean Griffey: 5
Patricia Racette: 5
Anthony Michaels-Moore: 4-5
John Doyles production: 4-5
Donald Runnicles: 4-5
Overall impression: 4-5