Nino Machaidze Romantic Arias

Nino Machaidze: Romantic arias. Sony 2011

Nino Machaidze, born 1983 in Tblisi, Georgia came to fame overnight as a late substitution for Anna Netrebko as Juliette in the 2008 Salzburg production of Romeo and Juliette partnering Rolando Villazon - also released on DVD. I was in Salzburg that summer, watchin the production in one of the plaza´s of the Old City, remembering all the fuss about her - her Angelina Jolie-like looks, her being somewhat overparted for the role, but generally doing well.
And after Salzburg has taken her to all the major houses, mainly in lyrical coloratura parts, especially Gilda and Juliette.
Admittedly it is difficult to be exposed like this, and as a young performer you have to be really careful. I cannot point my finger, as an outsider, to anything in particular that Nino Machaidze shouldn´t have done in the past three years, but listening to this, her first solo CD with Sony, is a major disappointment.

She is audibly strained in all the arias, with a wide unpleasant vibrato in both top and upper middle register. On top of that about half of her top notes are widely off-pitch. It takes away the attention from everything else and I have to admit it is really not pleasant to listen to this CD. And she is only 27. The publicity and her Angelina Jolie-good luks will sustain her career for a bit, I suppose. But in 5 years she will have a voice in ruins. Unless something radical happens.

Filles de Cadiz from Romantic Arias

.
Overall impression (scale from 1-5, 3=average): 1-2

Salzburg Romeo and Juliette on DVD

Romeo and Juliette. DVD. Salzburg Festival 2008. Production: Bartlett Sher. Cast: Nino Machaidze (Juliette), Rolando Villazón (Romeo), Mikhail Petrenko (Frére Laurent), Cora Burggraaf, Susanne Resmark(Gertrude). Conductor: Yannick Nézet-Séguin with the Mozarteum Orchestra.

The ticket-scalpers worst nightmare must have come through when Anna Netrebko cancelled her participation in this Salzburg production of Romeo and Juliette, to be replaced by Nino Machaidze next to Rolando Villazón. Blackmarket ticket prizes have fallen from approximately 1000+ Euros to something approximating the ordinary ticket prize, which at 360 Euro for the top seats may not exactly be called cheap either.
Bartlett Sher was accused of commercialism at it´s worsts well as selling out Salzburg´s soul  by the Salzburg Festival critics when this production opened the 2008 Salzburg Festiva. Audiences loved it, though. Though exactly how Bartlett Sher´s rather minimalistic staging elegantly utilizing the special stage of the Felsenreitschule represents commercialism at it´s worst is not apparent to me. All characters wore period costumes and the direction was engaging. Admittedly Bartlett Sher was not overly inventive, but I was nevertheless rather well entertained.

49-year old American Bartlett Sher, who previously directed the Barber of Seville at the Metropolitan Opera commented on the production: "My inspiration for the staging came from Patrice Chéreau´s film Bartholomeus Night. The costumes were inspired by Fellini´s Casanova.".."I intend to show Romeo and Juliette´s innocence in a decadent world...after each period of decadence a catastophe occurs before a new development may begin".

Obviously Anna Netrebko-replacement and Angelina Jolie look-a-like Nino Machaidze was chosen more for her looks than for her singing, where she was seriously overparted, but of a 25-year being thrown onto the glitzy Salzburg main stage and filmed mostly at her opening night, she was rather impressive. Supposedly if she had been more ordinarily-looking, her casting would have seemed less superficial..

Rolando Villazón was back in his right element vocally, now he only needs to be on pitch as well to be back on the track of old times. Susanne Resmark was excellent as Gertrude, the rest of the gentlemen less so, apart from the engaging performance from conductor Yannick Nézet-Séguin.

Rolando Villazón and Nino Machaidze, O nuit divine:

The bottom line (scale of 1-5, 3=average):

Rolando Villazon: 4
Nino Machaidze: 4
Mikhail Petrenko: 3

Yannick Nezet-Seguin: 5
Bartlett Sher´s production: 4

Overall impression: 4